If you want one list that holds items from every store, the best Amazon Wish List alternatives in 2026 are SwishWish (any-store links, reserving without an account, free), MyRegistry (the most mature universal registry, with a browser extension and store-registry imports), Giftster (best for extended families and recurring holiday lists), Throne (best for creators who need their address hidden), Elfster (best for Secret Santa and gift exchanges), Things To Get Me (simplest link-only list), and Moonsift (best for fashion and multi-store shopping boards). Amazon itself is still the right choice if you only ever shop on Amazon.
9 min read · Published 2026-09-20 · Updated 2026-09-20
Amazon Wish Lists used to be universal. The Amazon Assistant browser extension added an "Add to Wish List" button that worked on other retailers' product pages, so a single Amazon list could hold a jacket from one store, a board game from another, and a book from Amazon. Amazon discontinued that extension in March 2023, and with it the universal add. An Amazon Wish List now holds Amazon products, and nothing else.
That matters because almost nobody shops at one retailer. A birthday list realistically spans a marketplace, a specialist shop, and something from a small independent brand. Three lists in three places is not a list — it is homework for whoever is trying to buy you a present.
There are two other reasons people move. Amazon Wish Lists have no reliable way for a gift-giver to mark an item as taken without the recipient finding out, so duplicate gifts happen. And Amazon deliberately keeps wish lists out of search results, which is good for privacy but means you always have to hand over a link manually.
We have included the cases where each tool — including our own — is the wrong choice. A comparison that pretends the category leaders have no advantages is not useful to you and is not honest.
Best for: One shareable list that holds items from any store, with no account needed to reserve
SwishWish is our own product, so treat the placement with appropriate suspicion and read the drawbacks below. What it does: you paste a product URL from any online store and it pulls in the title, image, price and retailer automatically. You can keep several lists for different occasions, set each one private or public, and share a link. Whoever opens that link can reserve an item and mark it purchased without signing up — and the reservation is hidden from you, so you still get the surprise and they don't end up as the second person to buy the same thing. You can also DM an Instagram post or reel link to the connected SwishWish account and have it land on your wishlist, which is the fastest capture path we know of for things you spot while scrolling.
Strengths
Drawbacks
Best for: The most complete universal registry, especially for weddings and baby showers
MyRegistry is the incumbent in the universal-registry category and it earns the position. It has a browser extension that adds items from other retailers, it can pull in registries you already made at major stores so guests only need one link, and it has been running long enough that most people who plan events have heard of it. If your list is really a registry — a wedding, a baby shower, an event with a guest list — this is the strongest option on this page and it is not close.
Strengths
Drawbacks
Best for: Extended families who do the same gift exchange every year
Giftster is built around the family group rather than the individual list. You create a group, everyone joins, everyone keeps a list, and the group persists year after year so nobody re-invites Grandma every December. Reserved items are hidden from the recipient and visible to everyone else in the group, which is exactly the right model for a family of twelve buying across four households. Lists are deliberately not indexed by search engines.
Strengths
Drawbacks
Best for: Creators and streamers who need gifts shipped without revealing their address
Throne is the creator-economy answer and it solves a problem none of the general tools do: your audience can buy you something and it arrives without them ever seeing where you live. The whole product is built around a public throne.com/username page and privacy-first fulfilment. If you have an audience rather than a friends-and-family circle, start here. If you are making a birthday list for six people you know, it is the wrong shape.
Strengths
Drawbacks
Best for: Secret Santa and organised gift exchanges
Elfster owns the gift-exchange use case. It draws names, handles exclusion rules so couples do not draw each other, sends the reminders, and hangs a wishlist off each participant. As a general-purpose universal wishlist it is mediocre; as the thing that runs your office Secret Santa in December, nothing else here competes.
Strengths
Drawbacks
Best for: The simplest possible link-only list with nothing to learn
Things To Get Me does one thing: you paste links, you get a list at an unguessable URL, you send that URL to people. No groups, no social layer, no registry apparatus. Lists are not discoverable — the only way in is the link you gave out. If everything else on this page feels like too much software, this is the one to try.
Strengths
Drawbacks
Best for: Fashion and interiors shoppers who collect across many boutique stores
Moonsift is a shopping-first tool rather than a gifting-first one. Its browser extension saves products from a very wide range of retailers into visual boards, which makes it excellent for "everything I am considering for the living room" and for fashion wishlists that span a dozen small brands. It is a wishlist in the shopping sense more than the gifting sense — the reserve-and-surprise mechanics that make a birthday list work are not the focus.
Strengths
Drawbacks
| Any store by link | Reserve without account | Groups | Browser extension | Free core | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SwishWish | Yes | Yes | Yes (workspaces) | No | Yes |
| Amazon Wish List | No — Amazon only since 2023 | No | No | No | Yes |
| MyRegistry | Yes | Yes | Limited | Yes | Yes |
| Giftster | Yes | Group members only | Yes — core model | Yes | Yes |
| Throne | Curated catalogue | Yes | No | No | Yes |
| Elfster | Yes | Yes | Yes — exchanges | Yes | Yes |
| Things To Get Me | Yes | Yes | No | No | Yes |
| Moonsift | Yes | Limited | No | Yes | Yes |
Feature comparison, September 2026. Features change — check before you commit a wedding to one.
Genuinely: if every item you want is sold on Amazon, stay. Prime delivery, one checkout, gift receipts, and the fact that your relatives already have an account are real advantages that no independent tool replicates. The reason to leave is not that Amazon is bad at lists — it is that Amazon is only good at lists of Amazon products.
A reasonable middle path is to keep your Amazon list for Amazon items and add it as a single link inside a universal list, so the person buying still only needs one URL from you.
If you are still deciding whether a universal list is even the right model, what is a universal wishlist covers how they differ from a store registry.
No. Amazon discontinued the Amazon Assistant browser extension in March 2023, which removed the universal "Add to Wish List" button that worked on other retailers. Amazon Wish Lists now hold Amazon products only. To keep items from several stores in one list you need a universal wishlist tool.
SwishWish, Giftster and Things To Get Me all keep the core loop — create a list, add items from any store, share it, let people reserve — completely free. MyRegistry and Elfster are also free to use, with more commercial surface area around the product.
With SwishWish, MyRegistry, Elfster and Things To Get Me, no — anyone with the link can view the list and reserve an item without signing up. Giftster is the exception by design, because it is built around a family group that people join. Requiring an account is the most common reason a shared list goes unused.
On tools built for gifting, no. SwishWish and Giftster hide reservations from the list owner while showing them to other visitors, so duplicates are prevented and the surprise survives. Shopping-first tools do not always make this distinction, so check before you rely on it.
It depends on the tool and the setting. Amazon and Giftster keep lists out of search engines. MyRegistry indexes public registries so guests can find them by name. SwishWish starts every list private and lets you switch an individual list to public, with search discoverability as a separate opt-in that is off by default.
MyRegistry. It was built for registries, it imports lists you already made at major stores, and guests recognise it. The lighter tools on this page are better for personal lists than for events with a guest list and a thank-you-card spreadsheet.
Not to most of these tools. MyRegistry offers registry import from supported retailers; the others expect you to copy product URLs across, which takes a couple of minutes for a typical list because the title, image and price are fetched from each link for you.
A universal wishlist holds items from every store in one link. We ranked nine of them — SwishWish, MyRegistry, Giftster, Elfster, Throne and more — by who each one is actually for.
A universal wishlist holds items from every online store in one shareable link. Here is how link capture and reserving work, and when a store registry is still the better choice.
A practical guide to sharing a wishlist: when to send it, what to say so it is not awkward, how reserving prevents duplicate gifts, and the privacy settings to check first.
© 2026 SwishWish. All rights reserved.